- Acting of Lead Performers
- Acting of Supporting Cast
- Music Score
- Title Sequence
- Historical Importance
- Would You Recommend?
0 Member Ratings
NO REVIEWS AVAILABLE
The title has not been reviewed. Be the first to write a review by clicking here to start.
I always loved this film and personally fantasized the beach scene for myself many times. However, over the years I neglected to watch the film in full. I finally did on TCM's last showing. Sorry but the ending was absolutely stupid! After everything Monty Clift's character killed by friendly fire!? I was totally turned off on the entire movie! He couldn't die heroically? while I love both Donna Reed and Sinatra, I feel their performances were not oscar worth in this film! I have a different view of the film after watching it in full finally.
give me some old time religion..
because there is no way in hell or heaven.. I am buying enjoying a Deborah kerr movie. I am the Robert Osbourne to her tim Conway.. or ninja to shaolin ..or snake to.. you get the idea. like a slogan.. lock her movies up.
Academy Award well earned
- Goldenage of Hollywood
Great ensemble cast everyone fits like a fine puzzle piece. Zinnemann does a wonderful job directing everything. You are so engrossed with the characters that you forget about looming wwII. Monty Clift as Prewitt in the role of his life. Lancaster is also very good and I love how his relationship with Prewitt evolves to one of great love and respect. Sinatra does great and earns his Oscar as well as Reed. I can't for the life of me figure out how Clift did not win the Oscar. It was Karl Malden who said that Clift was underappreciated becase he so immersed himself in the character and story that he actually sinks into the story. He's not looking at it correctly. The character of Prewitt was never meant to be the standout but was the glue that made all the parts work. Clift understood that and he did it with reverence. It was an oscar worthy performance. James Jones who wrote the book sent a letter to one of the producers about the end of the film. It said he was hoping the "end would convey that life goes on, people move on, Prew's death is but a small ripple in a vast moving tide that stops to mourn for no man. If you get that right you've got the movie". Both Zinnemann and Clift got the movie.
Deborah Kerr in her break out American Role...
Deborah doesn't always act well......but.....she acts@.....My admiration for her goes beyond one or two films....She makes an effort to try many different roles...That is a major strength..She is on time, knows her liines, understands the work and so forthJudy Garland was equally gifted but couldn't carry her part....Disappointing...After British Black Narcussis, she found her way to America and stayed with us..She gave us 44 wonderful performances and enjoyed the work...As a fan....I enjoyed my time in the theater......My genuine view of her is that she was ahead of her time....From here to Eternity could have been improved as it comes across a bit childishly.....Burt Lancaster came on too strongly, and the film lacked subtlty....Impressive was Deborah Kerrs lack of her British Accent...All I could pick up was american....."To Mr. Dean.....".You mean (in Black Narcissus.)". Run away???.....No Ms. Kerr...not now....Not Ever....
response to previous review
- kevin sellers
I respectfully disagree with Don. What you would have gained with Rita H. (sexuality) would have been more than offset by a steep decline in acting ability. I mean, just take that ending with Karen Holmes and Alma on the ship, musing about their losses and bleak futures. With Deborah Kerr and Donna Reed, two fine actresses, it's heartbreaking. With Rita Hayworth and Donna Reed I wager to say it would have been quite a bit less than that, even with a great director of actresses like Zinnemann on board.
I've long proposed the fact if Rita Hayworth had been cast in the Deborah Kerr part, the sexual component required for the part, would have been properly satisfied. As it is, it's not bad, but without the sexual urgency required to tell the story, it's less than it might have been. Let's face it, Ms. Kerr has never been known as a "sexy" actress.With her quavering voice and gentle demeanor, she simply didn't evoke sexuality. Hayworth would have brought the world weary sexpot persona to life, improving the film and possibly brought home an Oscar.
From Here To Eternity
- Michael Whitty
An Academy Award winner for 1953 "From Here To Eternity" gives a tough and honest look at the Schofield Army Barracks in Hawaii before and during the Japanese attack on December 7, 1941. Focusing on the lives of the men in their training and their weekends at Honolulu night clubs this story had some memorable characters such as Prewitt who didn't want to join the boxing team so he suffered for it and Maggio who loved the nightclub atmosphere but ended up in the stockade. The women showed up well with Deborah kerr who has a fling with Burt Lancaster and Donna Reed who cozies up to Montgomery Clift's Prewitt. James Jones' novel was more inclusive but the movie did fine.....8 Academy Awards.
Mickey Shaughnessey is perfect !
- DON RILEY
I found Mickey Shaughnessey to be perfect in his role. This film just is not one that appealed to me. I found it to be too much like a soap opera. I saw little of actual substance. I liked some of the acting Montgomery Clift . I thought Donna Reed and Frank Sinatra were Ok, but nothing spectacular, that also goes for Burt Lancaster. I loved Merle Travis and his guitar playing but this just was not a great movie to me, its overrated in my opinion.
from here to eternity
- kevin sellers
Fred Zinnemann was always derided by the Cahiers du Cinema crowd 'cause he "lacked a personal style," which I guess means he didn't make variations on the same film over and over, like Sirk or Wilder or Hawks, to name three beloved by the auteurists. And while it's true that Zinnemann could be dull (The Search, the over-rated High Noon) he made a few films that are quite effecting, including The Nun's Story, The Sundowners, and this one. It's not a perfect film. It's got its flaws. I agree that Donna Reed is not hard enough to be playing a girl in a Honolulu brothel (they cleaned it up for Harry Cohn and called it a "club", but it's a brothel) and that Frank Sinatra is over the top, but aside from these quibbles I'm amazed that Zinnemann succeeded in capturing the spirit and most of the key events of James Jones great, extremely realistic war novel without watering it down. At least too much. And some of the scenes, like Pearl Harbor morning and the death of Pruitt and the ending, with Deborah Kerr (who, along with Montgomery Clift, delivers the best performance in the film) and Reed on board a ship leaving Hawaii and talking about loss and sorrow, are even better than the novel. Let's give it an A minus, and Andy Sarris be damned! P.S. I disagree with the previous reviewer who said George Reeves' scenes had not been cut. Think about it. He has one brief scene with Lancaster in the beginning and then we don't see him till Pearl Harbor, when he's the mess hall sergeant and the men are griping about his cooking, without any explanation why, which sure suggests a snip or two somewhere along the way.
For those who are railing against Sinatra getting the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor in this film, he deserved it. 1953 was a very weak year for films and the nominees in this category were particularly weak: Eddie Albert (Roman Holiday), Jack Palance (Shane), Brandon de Wilde (Shane), and Robert Strauss (Stalag 17). Sinatra's character in "From Here to Eternity" is essential to the film and he was in most of the film and was very good as well. While I believe he deserved the Best Actor Oscar for both "The Manchurian Candidate" and "The Man With the Golden Arm," he was very good in a host of other films too. In "From Here to Eternity," the two actors who just blew me away were Montgomery Clift and Burt Lancaster. Clift was so so broken in this film and it wrenches at your heart. Lancaster surprised me, as I am not a fan but couldn't look past his performance as the lover to the ambitious wife of his superior but a man loved by the men under his command too. The one performance I didn't care for was Donna Reed's, as I believe she was dreadfully miscast here as a B-girl. She simply didn't have the gravitas needed for this part. She won for Supporting Actress but, once again, the field was very weak that year!
From Here to There
Wow, Frank Sinatra couldn't act AT ALL, could he? Wonder how much he shelled out for his Oscar ...
Does anyone seriously believe that Sinatra gave an Academy Award performance? You've got to be kidding!
From Here to Eternity
Overall- 4 out of 5Lead Performers-5/5Supporting Cast-5/5Director-5/5Score-4/5Screenplay-3/5Cinematography-4/5Importance-3/5Recommendation for fans of the genre-4/5
From Here to Eternity
- Dashiell Barnes
The Best Picture winner of '53 is this toned-down, but still powerful melodrama adapted from Jones' novel . The lives of military men in Hawaii are interrupted by Pearl Harbour. Excellent performances overall; Clift, Lancaster & Kerr were nominated for their leading performances, and Sinatra & Reed won Oscars for their supporting roles. The film was also honoured for Zinnemann's direction, adapted screenplay, editing, cinematography & sound. Still a great film that tackles themes of adultery, prostitution, military injustice & murder. I give it a 5/5.
Finding Love in All the Wrong Moments of Time
- Eddie Foster
I thankfully purchased this film for my Kindle Fire on July 8, 2012 when Ernest Borgnine died and boy what an incredible movie. I kept passing the movie up because I didn't know what to expect of it. I knew it would be a love story (iconic scene with Burt Lancaster and Deborah Kerr) and I knew it would be a war film. I didn't know that everything in the character's lives was a personal battle. Montgomery Clift's character was the most fascinating in the bunch along with Lancaster and so were all of the supports (Frank Sinatra and Donna Reed in Academy Award winning roles). The direction and the screenplay really brought all of the characters together. A solid picture. A must-see.
Pure classic cinema...
- Steve S.
Except for the unhappy ending (yes, I'm a sucker for happy endings) I can't find a thing "wrong" with this film.Reed and Kerr simply knock my sock's off and the rest of the cast, script, direction etc are suberb!
when i was a kid, my mom almost killed when I accidently recorded over her copy. i don't think she ever completely forgave me. i tried to make it up to her by buy her a a ten tape box set that had movies by John Wayne Humphrey Bogart and Alan Ladd among others
from here to eternity
Although this was a terrfic movie and I really like Frank Sinatra, I don't think he should have won the academy award.
Contains a movie myth
- Mr. Blandings
The oft-repeated cinema myth regarding this film is that the test audience giggled and called out "Superman!" whenever actor George Reeves appeared on the screen, and that this prompted the worried director to cut down the actor's parts drastically. Well - as it is with all myths and urban legends - this one is patently false. According to the *director himself* (and he would know) all that he filmed of Reeves is right there in the final movie; there were no deleted parts, and if anyone recognized the actor they sure didn't let on vocally. It is time that this myth was put to rest, so hopefully the next time this movie airs on TCM, I hope the hosts will do some research first, check on the director's own words, and not just lazily pass on what is a lie ... and an insult to both the actor and the director.
- kyle rhoads
This is one, if not my favorite war film of all time i love this movie!!! all the great qualities that make a masterpiece!!!
Who wouldn't want a romp in the sand.
Good, but could have been great
- Dennis Kirsch
I've seen it several times, and always enjoyed it. However, I later read the book, and felt the movie could have been much better if it had followed the book more closely. However, at the time it was filmed, Donna Reed as a prostitute would likely not have played so well to American audiences.
From Here To Eternity
This is all about those "once in a life time converging factors" when every thing was right at the exact moment it was filmed. I want more from this movie: story, the actors, the directions, costumes, scenery everything! For the audience of the 1950's this was as good as it got. As an average film goer of today I still get it. I want more from everyone on that screen. And the kissing in the surf scene is still hot even by today's "anything goes" standards.Funny, in an odd piece of irony, I would pay the nine dollars for a theater ticket to see this masterpiece in the large theater. I cannot say that about most movies being presented today.
Another Oscar-Winning Wartime Romance.
- Frank Harris Horn
Fred Zinneman assembles a magnificent all-star cast led by Burt Lancaster and Deborah Kerr, and going on location in Honolulu and Pearl Harbor, Hawaii to film one of the great wartime romances of the 20th century. Based on James Jones' best-seller set in pre-World War II Hawaii, it tells of the illicit love affair between a U.S. Army sergeant (Lancaster) and the beautiful wife (Kerr) of the base commander, and how their lives will be affected by the oncoming Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. Winner of eight Academy Awards including Best Picture, Zinneman as Best Director, co-stars Frank Sinatra as Best Supporting Actor, and Donna Reed as Best Supporting Actress, Best Screenplay Adaptation, Best Cinematography (B&W), Best Sound Recording and Best Film Editing. Aloha, My Hawaii. Also starring Montgomery Clift, Phillip Ober, Ernest Borgnine, Jack Warden, Mickey Shaughnessy, Harry Bellaver, George Reeves, John Dennis, Claude Akins, Tim Ryan, Merle Travis, Joan Shawlee, Robert Karnes, Douglas Henderson, John Bryant, Mary Carver, Robert J. Wilke, Carleton G. Young, Don Dubbins & Willis Bouchey.
Love, love, love it!
One of the masterpieces of movie making. Truly romantic setting in gorgeous Hawaii, superb acting and a wonderful cast of characters whose lives intertwine for better or worse in the days prior to the attack on Pearl Harbor. The love affairs, the in-fighting between soldiers, the cruelty of bullies, the romance of the era. This movie has it all. I'm only sorry Deborah Kerr didn't win an Oscar for her performance here (or ever) or Burt Lancaster. Amazing performances. The sex appeal between the two stars is mind blowing. I wish I were inside this film. I love all the performances and am happy the Academy at least recognized Donna Reed and Sinatra for Oscars.Lancaster, Kerr, Clift, Sinatra, Reed, Borgnine, et al.LOVE IT!! 5 *****
One of the Truly Great Ones!!!
Beginning to end, one of the best!!! In all degrees!
A must see
This movie was just one of the best. Montgomery Clift, Burt Lanchaster, Ernest Borgnine, Frank Sinatra, Etc, Etc, Etc. Their performances were stellar. We don't even have to talk about the beach scene which is still to this day one of the sexiest things on film!
Definitive World War II Classic
- Bob Hendrick
When I think of great films about World War II, this is the first one that comes to mind. Fred Zinneman's black and white masterpiece. Burt Lancaster won best actor that year at the SAG Awards; but lost the Oscar to William Holden. Both were great, but I think the nod should have gone to Lancaster. Sinatra, Monty Clift, and Deborah Kerr were outstanding; and Donna Reed copped the supporting actress Oscar. Taradash's adapted screenplay was brilliant; and that beach scene with Lancaster and Kerr is to this day, the sexiest scene ever filmed. What a movie!
Great movie, just wonderful
This is considered one of the greatest movies of all time, and deserves the title. Everything about this is great. The acting is superb- all 5 of the movie's major performers were nominated for Oscars, and two won (Donna Reed for supporting actress and Frank Sinatra for supporting actor) It's a romantic and exciting story. The leading ladies are great in their roles. And to think Donna Reed's character was a prostitute yet they made it in these days without nudity or strong sexual content. Great all-around movie, I recommend it for anyone!